Podcast Overview
You join as the Technical SEO.
Headphones on. Fixing penalties. Tapping your feet to your music until someone downstairs complains.
Eight years later, you own the agency.
No lump sum. No external investors. Just a payment plan, a Founder who trusts you, and that 2am realisation that everything is now on you.
That’s the journey of Giorgio Cassella, Co-Owner of Sheffield’s Evoluted.
Giorgio joined Evoluted in 2018 as a Technical SEO Manager, moved up to Head of Marketing, became joint Managing Director alongside Sam Biggins in 2022, and together they bought the agency from Founder Ash Young through a management buyout after 16 years of independent ownership.
Evoluted is a full-service eCommerce agency, a certified B Corp and the team behind CarMats.co.uk. Giorgio also founded its digital marketing events, which started in a pub at Sheffield train station and now run across Sheffield, Nottingham, Manchester and London.
This podcast episode is relevant to you if you’re a Founder weighing up how to exit, a senior leader who might one day buy the business you run, or an agency owner trying to step out of the day to day by giving your heads of department real ownership.
Giorgio walks Richard through how the buyout came together in roughly six months, why they chose an MBO over selling to a network or going employee owned, and the gap that opened up once he went from “the employee who runs the show” to the person responsible for everything. He explains how they built a senior leadership team with clear mandates, spending limits and targets, and how the Co-MD split works, with Giorgio guarding every coin “like a dragon on a pile of gold” and Sam leading people and process.
The conversation also covers why Evoluted focuses on £3m to £10m eCommerce brands, the “fun, fame, fortune” test for exceptions, and the 16 years of failed experiments behind CarMats.co.uk. Giorgio shares hard-won event lessons, admits B Corp has never won Evoluted a single client, and argues that for some clients AI is still around 1.5% of monthly revenue, so objectivity matters more than hype.
If you’re thinking about buying, selling or stepping back from an agency, this episode is a rare inside look at how a management buyout works when trust is already in place.
Listen now!
Topics Covered
00:00 – From employee to agency owner
05:50 – Transitioning leadership at Evoluted
09:32 – Transitioning from SEO manager to owner
11:42 – Choosing a Business Exit Strategy
15:15 – Strengthening management team structure
19:42 – Managing finances and revenue systems
23:31 – The journey of trial and error
25:06 – Discussing agency client selection factors
28:59 – Balancing budgets in early agency growth
31:35 – Discussing budget expectations with clients
35:04 – Creating a laid-back marketing community
38:28 – Overcoming fear of first events
40:12 – Managing event attendees
43:06 – Networking at company events
47:43 – Adapting to eCommerce changes
51:30 – Book recommendation